Boats and Aeroplanes
How can a boat made of steel float when a steel nail sinks? And how does an aeroplane stay up? Beakman climbs into a tank of water to show what displacement means, pushes a straw through a raw potato, and calls in Balance Man to blow on a sheet of paper and explain the secret of the wing.
How Can a Steel Boat Float?
It is all about the water the boat pushes aside. When Beakman climbed into the full tank, water slopped out, because he pushed it aside: that is displacement. A floating boat is held up by water weighing exactly as much as the boat. Shape a sheet of foil into a boat and it pushes aside a lot of water and floats. Crush the same foil into a ball and it pushes aside hardly any, so it sinks.
With its wings, not its engine. Beakman's toy plane with the wings pulled off went fast but did not fly. A wing is shaped so that the air pressure above it is lower than the air pressure below it, and the higher pressure underneath pushes the plane up. Balance Man explains it, once Josie has stopped being disappointed that Beakman missed him again.
Have a Guess
Have a guess for each one before you tap. Trust your gut.
It floats. The beaker of marshmallows weighs less than the beaker of water, even though they take up the same space, so marshmallow is less dense than water. Anything less dense than the stuff it is in will float on it. A beaker of nails weighs more than the water, so a nail sinks.
Yes. A straw is a cylinder, and a cylinder is one of the strongest shapes there is, like a table with so many legs that they all touch. Pushed straight on, a paper tube can hold up a brick. Push it from the side, though, and it folds at once.
It lifts up. Blowing across the top makes the air pressure there lower than the pressure underneath, and the higher pressure underneath pushes the paper up into the low-pressure area. Stop blowing and the pressures balance again and the paper droops. That is the secret of the wing.
Fast, Fun, Furious Facts
Eight fast facts from the show and the science. True or false? Tap fast, think faster.
Score:
Best streak:
Let's Find Out
Tap each card to find out more. Four cards for boats, four for aeroplanes.
Key Ideas
Density
Tap to learn moreDensity is how much stuff is packed into a space. Beakman's beaker of marshmallows and beaker of water took up the same room, but the water weighed more, so water is denser. Something floats if it is less dense than what it is in, and sinks if it is denser.
Displacement
Tap to learn moreWhen Beakman got into the full tank, water spilled out because he pushed it aside. That is displacement. If you collected all the spilt water and weighed it, it would weigh exactly as much as Beakman. A floating thing always pushes aside water that weighs the same as itself.
Why the Boat Floats and the Ball Sinks
Tap to learn moreTake a boat out of the water and there is a boat-shaped hole. The boat must weigh the same as the water that fills that hole, or it sinks. A foil boat makes a big hole and pushes aside plenty of water. Crush it into a ball and it makes a tiny hole, pushes aside hardly any water, and weighs more than the water it displaces. So it sinks.
Salt Water Floats You Higher
Tap to learn moreSalt water is denser than fresh water, so it pushes up harder on anything in it. That is why you float more easily in the sea than in a swimming pool. In the very salty Dead Sea, people can lie back and float while reading a newspaper.
Air Pressure Seeks Balance
Tap to learn moreBalance Man's whole job is to remind us that nature seeks balance. Air pressure is the same all round a sheet of paper until you blow across the top. Then the pressure up there drops, and the higher pressure underneath pushes the paper up towards the low-pressure area until things balance again.
The Secret of the Wing
Tap to learn moreA wing is curved on top and flatter underneath. As the plane moves, the air flowing over the curved top ends up at a lower pressure than the air underneath, so the wing is caught between low pressure above and higher pressure below. It gets pushed up. Pilots have kept gliders, planes with no engine at all, in the air for 24 hours.
Firsts and Fastest
Tap to learn moreOn 17 December 1903 Orville Wright flew the first plane with an engine and controls: 37 metres (120 feet), about three school buses, in 12 seconds. The Spruce Goose, which flew once in 1947, had the widest wings ever at nearly 100 metres (320 feet). The SR-71 Blackbird has been clocked at more than 3,500 kilometres an hour (2,193 miles an hour), about three times the speed of sound.
Four Forces of Flight
Tap to learn moreFour forces act on every plane. Weight pulls it down, lift from the wings holds it up, thrust from the engines pushes it forward, and drag from the air holds it back. To stay up, the lift must match the weight; to speed up, the thrust must beat the drag.
A Visitor From History
No scientist from history dropped in this week (Balance Man is strictly a superhero), so meet the man who worked out why things float, famously in his bath.
Archimedes, who lived in Syracuse in Sicily more than two thousand years ago. The story goes that he was asked whether the king's new crown was pure gold, got into a full bath, noticed the water slop over the side, and shouted "Eureka!", which means "I have found it." Whether or not the bath happened, he wrote down the rule.
His rule is Beakman's tank in one sentence. Anything in water is pushed up by a force equal to the weight of the water it pushes aside. A boat pushes aside its own weight in water and floats; a crushed ball cannot push aside enough, so it sinks. Our simulation weighs the water for you.
Try It: Beakman's Bathtub
Shape the same piece of foil into a ball, a bowl or a boat, load it with marbles, and see what the water does.
The same foil every time. Its weight never changes, but its shape changes how much water it can push aside. While it floats, the water it pushes aside weighs exactly what it weighs: Archimedes' rule.
Use What You Know
Time to use what you know. Match the four things to their descriptions, then take on the challenge.
Match Them Up
Tap an item to pick it, then tap the box it belongs to.
Real World Challenge
A cargo ship sits higher in the water when it is empty and lower when it is full, and it has a line painted on its side showing the deepest it may safely go. Explain what is happening with the words displacement and weight, and what would happen if the line went under. Then watch a bird land: what do its wings do just before it touches down, and why does that work?
What Has Changed Since This Episode
This episode first aired in November 1992. Boats still float by Archimedes' rule, but one part of the wing story has been corrected, and two of the aeroplane records have fallen.
Now we know: Not quite. NASA calls that the equal transit time idea and lists it as an incorrect explanation. The air over the top really does go faster and really is at lower pressure, but the two streams never meet up again: the top air gets to the back first. The honest short version is that the wing turns the air downwards, and the air pushes the wing up in return.
Now we know: Not since 2019. The Stratolaunch Roc, an aeroplane built to carry rockets up and launch them from the air, first flew in April 2019 with a wingspan of 117 metres (385 feet). It has two fuselages, side by side, and a pilot in only one of them.
Now we know: It is still the fastest jet with a pilot on board. But in 2004 NASA's X-43A, a small unpiloted plane dropped from a bomber, flew at nearly 11,000 kilometres an hour (7,000 miles an hour), Mach 9.6, using a scramjet, a jet engine with no moving parts that only works at enormous speed. It flew for about ten seconds and then fell into the sea, as planned.
Show What You Know
Answer these and get an instant tick or a nudge. How many can you get?
Results
Your score:
Think About It
Next time you are in the bath, notice how the water rises when you get in and falls when you get out. Could you work out your own weight from it? Then hold your hand out flat from a car window (with a grown-up's permission) and tilt it slowly. What does the air do to it?
Episode Discussion
Share your thoughts on this Beakman's World episode